Franchise consultant, franchise broker, or going direct?


There are three ways people end up looking at franchises, and most people don't realize they've picked one until they're already inside it.
You can go straight to a brand. You can work with somebody in the middle: a consultant, a broker, a coach, an advisor (the titles vary). Or you can do both at once, which is more common than you'd think and occasionally causes problems.
Here's an honest description of both routes, including the part where I tell you how I get paid.
Route one: straight to the franchisor
You find a brand you like, you fill out the form on their site, and a development rep calls you back.
What's good about this: it's direct and you're talking to the people who actually have the answers. Anything specific about that business (what it costs to open, what the agreement requires of you, whether owners are making money) can only come from the franchisor and their disclosure document anyway. Nobody in the middle can answer those questions for them.
The challenge with this approach is that you most likely have not really thought through the characteristics you are looking for in a business and it can be difficult to know what are the characteristics of the business you are reaching out to. Most of us visit a business or read about one and think, "I think that sounds like a great business." Often, it isn't until after you have gone deep into the process, or worse, signed and started with a franchise, that you find out it wasn't really a good match or the financials really didn't meet your expectations. The other challenge is that many popular franchises get hundreds of inquiries and they really don't know if you'll be a great candidate so your application may be low on their priority list.
What to know going in: the person who calls you back works in franchise development. Their job is to award franchises for that one brand. A good development rep will disqualify you if you're not a fit for them, and many of them are genuinely straight with people. But they are not going to tell you that a different industry would suit you better, because that isn't their job.
The other thing is scope. If you go direct, you're evaluating the brands you happened to have heard of. Franchising is much wider than the names you can picture, and almost everybody starts out assuming it means food and retail. That assumption costs people the option they'd actually have liked.
Route two: somebody in the middle
This is where the titles get slippery, so let's deal with them first.
Consultant, coach, advisor, or broker. These are marketing words, but do have some legal implications. In the states that regulate this activity, the term in the statute is franchise broker, and what determines whether it applies to you is what you actually do, not the word on your business card. Here is the big difference. A broker is typically part of one franchisor's sales process. I'm not tied to any single brand, so my job is to find the right fit among many. As an independent consultant, coach or advisor, which is what I am, my role is to find out what specific characteristics you are looking for in a business and match them with franchise opportunities. I don't recommend you choose any one in particular. What I will do is take you through a process that allows you to discover what you are looking for and then you will make that decision for yourself. For example, I'll ask you questions about income goal, number of locations, work hours, number and type of employees, various industries and your past experiences and likes and dislikes of specific roles you performed in the past. Only after that, I will research franchise categories and hundreds of brands that match your characteristics and are available in the territory you are looking for. I will then provide you a warm introduction to a few of the best matched franchises, which is more important than one might think. I provide them with a full package on each candidate, background, financials and interest, so the franchisor knows these are potentially highly qualified candidates. Once you are in the discovery process with 3-4 franchises, I will be a resource for you all the way until you make an informed decision on which brand best fits the financial and lifestyle goals you are looking for.

How the money actually works
This is the question people are too polite to ask, so I'll answer it before you have to.
There's no cost to you. When a match is made, the franchise company pays a placement fee to the national consulting network I'm affiliated with, and that's how I'm compensated. It doesn't add anything to what you pay.
What I'd say about it is this. My incentive over twenty years is that people trust me enough to send me their kids, friends and their former colleagues, and that only happens if I'm willing to be honest with people and give them enough information to make an informed decision.
The three questions the FTC says to ask
The Federal Trade Commission publishes a consumer guide to buying a franchise. It is short, free, and worth twenty minutes of anybody's time. On the subject of brokers/consultants it says something worth quoting: "Some brokers represent any franchisor willing to pay them a commission for a sale." It also notes that a broker representing only a few franchisors will give you limited suggestions.
Then it gives you three questions to ask. Here they are, and here are my answers.
How many franchisors do you represent? I'm affiliated with a national consulting network with a portfolio of hundreds of prescreened brands across a wide range of industries: home services, senior care, business-to-business services, health and fitness, children's education, pet care, professional services, automotive, and yes, food. It is a substantial portfolio with many established and emerging brands that are constantly being vetted by our industry experts to provide you with opportunities that match what you are looking for.
How do you select the franchisors you represent? The network has been around for over 25 years. It holds those relationships and does the vetting before a brand is in the portfolio at all. They use a variety of criteria to narrow down the options so you don't have to. Based on our consultation, I narrow the list down to those that best match what you tell me is important to you and I'll tell you my reasoning for every single one on the list.
Who pays the broker and how is the payment calculated? The franchise company pays a placement fee to the network when a match is made. It doesn't change what you pay.
What somebody in the middle can't do for you
Worth being clear about, because it's often oversold.
I can't tell you what a specific franchise earns. Neither can anybody else. Financial performance information, where a brand chooses to publish it, lives in Item 19 of that brand's Franchise Disclosure Document, and it, along with your due diligence, comes with the context and the caveats that make it mean something. A figure quoted to you in a phone call or on a website has been stripped of all of that. Anyone on the internet quoting you franchise earnings is either guessing or breaking the rules.
I can't tell you what a specific franchise costs to open. Same reason. That's Item 7 of the disclosure document, and it comes from the brand.
I can't do your diligence for you. You'll talk to existing owners yourself: the happy ones and the unhappy ones. You'll read the disclosure document, which by federal rule you must receive at least fourteen days before you sign anything or pay anything. I suggest you bring in a franchise attorney and your own accountant.
What I can do is ask better questions than you'd ask yourself, narrow hundreds of options down to a handful that actually fit how you want to spend your time, tell you the truth about what ownership demands from having done it three times, and stay in your corner while you find out.
So which route
I'd argue that working with a consultant like me is the smartest first step, and here's why. It costs you nothing but a few hours of your time. In return, you'll get a clearer sense of whether ownership really suits you, sort out what you want in a business and what you want to avoid, and learn about types of businesses you probably never would have considered. When you've narrowed things down, I'll give you a warm introduction to the brands that fit best.
A question worth asking
What is the difference between a franchise consultant and a franchise broker?
The titles can overlap in practice. What matters is how the person gets paid, which brands they represent, and what independent due diligence you still need to do. Ask about compensation and incentives before relying on recommendations.
There's no cost and no obligation at any point. And if the answer at the end is that you should go directly to a brand you found on your own, I'll tell you that. Let's talk.



Comments